Custom Sugar Cookies2018-09-19T12:02:10+00:00

CUSTOM SUGAR COOKIES

CUSTOM SUGAR COOKIES ARE MORE THAN “JUST A COOKIE”

Lots and LOTS of work goes into each and every decorated cookie! This process is truly a labor of love that starts with researching the party theme, prepping the dough, cutting out the shapes (sometimes with the finickiest of cookie cutters), mixing icing colors of various consistencies, decorating and, finally, packaging. On average, one cookie can be touched 6 to 10 times depending on the intricacy and detail of the design.

PRICE

Our custom sugar cookies average $4.00 to $7.00 each with a minimum order of 24. If you prefer not to order the minimum, there is a $25 design fee.  Most ellenJAY cookie collections have 3 coordinating designs and are approximately $5 per cookie.  Hand-painted or airbrushed metallics are an additional $1 per cookie.

CUSTOM ORDER LEAD TIME

We recommend ordering your custom sugar cookies at least 2 weeks in advance.  It’s never too early to book your order.

PACKAGING

We can individually bag and heat-seal your cookies for an additional $0.50 each. We also offer individual favor packaging (tied with coordinating satin ribbon) for an additional $1.00 per cookie.  We have several gift box options in various sizes to create the perfect sweet gift.  Gift boxes are $3.00 each.

Contact Us

Contact us to start creating your custom sugar cookie order!